I first discovered Brooklyn Cloth about five years ago, when a friend with a sharp eye for streetwear insisted I try their henley. I was skeptical — online-only brands had let me down before, with flimsy seams and fabrics that pill after two washes. But that henley changed my mind. It held its shape, the stitching stayed tight, and the color didn't fade. Since then, I've bought their sweaters, joggers, and even a trench coat. So what is Brooklyn Cloth quality like? After wearing these pieces through seasons and repeated laundering, I have a thorough answer.
The Fabric Story
Brooklyn Cloth uses a mix of cotton, polyester blends, and some specialty fabrics like French terry and pique knit. For a brand that prices most items under $100, the fabric quality is genuinely impressive. Their heavyweight cotton sweaters, for example, have a substantial feel — not the thin, flimsy knit you'd expect at $60. The French terry is brushed on the inside for softness but retains structure on the outside. Even their basic tees, around $30, are made from a 6 oz. cotton that resists sagging. That said, not every piece hits the same mark. Some of their lighter layering pieces use a thinner polyester-cotton blend that can feel a bit plasticky, but those are the minority. Overall, when you ask what is Brooklyn Cloth quality like, the answer is far better than most direct-to-consumer brands in this price bracket.
Construction and Details
Good fabric means nothing without solid construction. Over the years, I've checked the seams, buttons, and finishing on every Brooklyn Cloth piece I own. The stitching is consistently straight and secure, with double-needle hems on tees and flatlock seams on activewear. Zippers — a common weak point — are YKK on the jackets I've tried, which is a reassuring standard. The trench coat I bought has taped seams and weighted buttons, details you'd find on pieces costing three times as much. However, I have noticed that some of their lighter jersey items can develop loose threads after aggressive washing. But that's the exception, not the rule. When I ask myself what is Brooklyn Cloth quality like in terms of craftsmanship, I'd say it's a solid B+ — exactly what you hope for from a brand that bridges casual and elevated.
Fit for Real Bodies
Fit is where Brooklyn Cloth really wins me over. I'm 5'6" with a straight build, and their standard sizes work without tailoring. But I've also heard from readers who are curvier that the women's cuts are generous without being boxy. The brand offers extended sizes up to 3XL on many styles, and the fit models clearly represent a range of body types. Their joggers have a tapered leg that doesn't look sloppy, and the sweaters have enough length to wear with leggings. For a woman over 40, Brooklyn Cloth avoids the twin pitfalls of too-tight influencer cuts or shapeless sacks. It's a Goldilocks fit. So when a reader emails me asking what is Brooklyn Cloth quality like, I always mention the fit as a standout feature.
Value Proposition
Let's talk dollars. A Brooklyn Cloth sweater runs $60–$80, a hoodie around $70, and their outerwear from $90 to $150. Compare that to similar styles from Everlane or Madewell, where sweaters are often $100+. The quality is comparable — sometimes better — at a lower price point. Their sales are frequent, with seasonal drops of 20–30% off. I've snagged a cashmere blend cardigan for $45 during a sale, and it's held up for three winters. Is it luxury? No. But for everyday pieces that look polished enough for a client call and comfortable enough for a long weekend, the value is hard to beat. For what is Brooklyn Cloth quality like in the context of value, I'd say it's an A-: you're getting more than you paid for, especially if you buy during a markdown.
How Does Brooklyn Cloth Compare to Everlane?
If you've shopped Everlane, you know their strengths: transparent pricing, minimalist design, and a cult following. But when I compare a Brooklyn Cloth heavyweight crewneck ($68) to an Everlane cashmere crew ($128), the Brooklyn Cloth feels heavier and more substantial. The cotton is thicker, the ribbing is tighter, and after a year of wear, it looks newer. The Everlane cashmere pilled after three months. For denim, Brooklyn Cloth's stretch jeans ($75) have held their shape better than my Everlane '90s cheeky jeans ($98), which relaxed at the knees within hours. That said, Everlane wins on polish: their trousers and blazers have sharper tailoring. But if what is Brooklyn Cloth quality like is your main question, I'd say it surpasses Everlane in casual staples, especially sweaters and joggers. For the price, Brooklyn Cloth delivers equal or better durability.
Final Verdict
Brooklyn Cloth won't replace a Hermès scarf or a Loro Piana sweater. But that's not the point. This brand delivers dependable, well-made staples at accessible prices. The quality is consistent, the fit is inclusive, and the fabrics are thoughtfully chosen. If you're a woman over 40 who wants to look put-together without a lot of fuss, Brooklyn Cloth is a brand worth adding to your rotation. And if you're still wondering what is Brooklyn Cloth quality like, my advice is simple: order one piece — I'd start with the heavyweight cotton crewneck — and judge for yourself. I think you'll be pleasantly surprised.
No letters yet — be the first to write.